Evaluate the Effectiveness of Acupressure on Menstrual Pain Perception among
Adolescent girls with Dysmenorrhea
Prof. P. Padmavathi
Principal,
Dhanvantri College of Nursing, Pallakkapalyam, Namakkal District -637 303
*Corresponding
Author’s Email: padmasekar2009@gmail.com
ABSTRACT:
Dysmenorrhea is a
leading cause for short-term school absence in adolescent school girls. In many
girls it has also decrease their quality of life. In India 67.2% adolescent
girls suffer from dysmenorrhea and 60% of them have disrupted daily routines. Statement of the problem: A study to evaluate the effectiveness of
acupressure on menstrual pain among adolescent girls with dysmenorrheal.
Methods: The research design adopted was True experimental design. The
study conducted at SDA School, Erode. The study was conducted on 30 adolescent girls (15 in control
group and 15 in experimental group). Experimental group received acupressure.
The levels of menstrual pain were assessed in both groups. Results: The study
concluded that in control group majority (70%) of them had severe pain and 30% of them
had moderate pain whereas in experimental group most (93%) of them had mild
pain and 7% of them had moderate pain. The overall mean percentage was 68% in
control group whereas in experimental group 30% with ‘t’ value 4.26 in control
group whereas in experimental group 18.47, significant at P < 0.05).
KEYWORDS: Effectiveness, acupressure, adolescent
girls, menstrual pain perception.
INTRODUCTION:
Adolescence [10-19 yrs] is a
period of growth which involves a stage of developmental transition and a
bridge between childhood and adulthood. Nearly 10-20% of world population
comprises of adolescents. In India one-fifth of the population [239 million]
are adolescents between age group of 10-19 yrs.1 Female adolescents’
account for the same proportion for the total female population as male
adolescents for the male population. The population survey in Karnataka shows
that 21 % of the total populations are
adolescents.
Menstruation is the hallmark
of female pubertal development; it is a normal physiological cycle, common to
all girls of reproductive age group. In some culture, menstruation is
considered dirty and is not fit to take part in social and religious activity.
Nearly half of the adolescent
girls are unaware of the phenomena of menstruation prior to its onset and are
therefore scarred at the time of its onset and unaware to disclose the problems
related to menstruation to anyone. The prevalence of dysmenorrhea is very high
and at least 50% of the women experience this problem throughout their
reproductive years. Painful menstruation also called as primary dysmenorrhea is
characterized by spasmodic or colicky pain and is worse on I, II, III days of
menses. It usually occurs in girls and young females and tends to decrease with
increasing age. (Arminder Singh, 2005) Dysmenorrhea
is a leading cause for short-term school absence in adolescent school girls. In
many girls it has also decrease their quality of life. In India 67.2%
adolescent girls suffer from dysmenorrhea and 60% of them have disrupted daily
routines. A study conducted in USA showed that 58% of girls suffered from
severe menstrual flow, smoking and depression are some of the risk factors for
dysmenorrhea. (French, 2005) Adolescent girls had been studied for menstrual
problems and data were collected by personal interviews on a pre-tested
semi-structured questionnaire. The result revealed that daily routines of the
60% girls were affected due to prolonged bed rest, missed school activities,
disturbed sleep and decreased appetite. [7.24% had not been able to attend
classes, 25% of them had to be abstained from work]. Hence there is a need to
emphasize on designing menstrual health program for adolescent girls.(Sharma,
2007) A study was conducted in West Indies to determine the prevalence of
dysmenorrhea on Hispanic female adolescents shows that 85% of them reported
dysmenorrhea, 38% reported missing school due to dysmenorrhea, 33% reported
missing individual classes. Activities affected included class concentration
[59%], sports [51%], class participation [50%], socialization [46%], and
homework [35%], test-taking skills [36%], and grades [29%]. Treatment taken for
dysmenorrheal included rest [58%], medications [52%], heating pad [26%], tea
[20%], exercise [15%] and herbs [7%]. The study concluded that adolescent girls
with dysmenorrhea are affected by lack of attendance to school, concentration
and other daily activities.
A variety of
non-pharmaceutical measures are being used for reducing the pain during
menstruation such as relaxation therapy, breathing techniques, touch and
massage, music therapy, application of heat and cold, acupressure and
acupuncture etc (Gurates,2008). Many studies have proved acupressure
helps in reducing the primary dysmenorrhea. Acupressure techniques are one of
the popular ancient alternative and complementary therapies. Recent research focusing on complementary
and alternative interventions for dysmenorrhea include the use of muscle
relaxation therapy, magnetic therapy, reflexology, hand acupuncture, moxibustion heat therapy, aroma therapy, acupuncture and
acupressure. Acupuncture and acupressure are based on traditional Chinese
medicine and share the main principle of opening and harmonizing an obstructed
meridian by stimulating surrounding acupuncture points. Experimental studies on acupressure and acupuncture have
demonstrated their effectiveness in alleviating discomfort through sedative and
analgesic effects. Many studies have shown that acupuncture is effective for
pain relief in general and acupuncture of specific sites such as the SP6 point
has been reported to alleviate dysmenorrhea. The SP6 acupoint
is the junction point of the liver, spleen, and kidney meridians, and it is
proposed to strengthen the spleen, resolve and expel dampness, and restore
balance to the Yin and blood, liver, and kidneys.
Acupressure can be adopted as
nursing interventions to alleviate dysmenorrhea improve productivity,
creativity, work performance and quality of life. It is a healing act using the
fingers to skillfully press the points which stimulate the body’s natural self,
creative abilities. When these trigger points are pressed, it releases muscular
tension and promote circulation of blood and body’s life force energy to aid
healing. Acupressure point called ‘SP6’ point is used for menstruation pain.
This point is located in 4 fingers above the lateral medial malleolus
bone. (Wong et.al, 2009)
An experimental study was
conducted among 58 Korean young college women in two universities to evaluate
the effects of the SP-6 acupressure on dysmenorrhea. The experimental group
received acupressure within first 8hr of menstruation and the severity of
dysmenorrhea was assessed prior to and 30min, 1, 2 and 3hr following the
treatment. The results revealed that there was a significant difference in
severity of dysmenorrheal between the two groups immediately after [F=18.50,
P=0.000] and for unto 2hr [F=8.04, P=0.032] post treatment. It was concluded
that acupressure to SP6 meridian can be an effective non-invasive nursing
intervention for alleviation of primary dysmenorrhea, with effects lasting 2hr
post treatment.
The nurse has an important
task in conducting school health programme and
educating adolescent girls as well as community regarding the various
non-pharmaceutical measures and its effectiveness in controlling menstrual pain
perception. In turn such education helps the adolescent girls to be equipped
and empowered with knowledge and skills to face the future effectively.
During school health programme, the investigator observed that most of the girls
were absent due to painful menstruation or primary dysmenorrheal. Hence based
on the above information, the researcher is motivated to act on and implement
the pain relief measures for adolescent girls and empower them to manage
dysmenorrhea. Hence the study is intended to assess the effectiveness of
acupressure on menstrual pain perception among adolescent girls in selected
schools.
STATEMENT OF THE PROBLEM:
A study to evaluate the
effectiveness of acupressure on menstrual pain among adolescent girls with
dysmenorrhea at selected schools in Erode.
OBJECTIVES:
1. To assess the level of menstrual pain among
control adolescent girls with dysmenorrhea before and after acupressure
2. To assess the level of menstrual pain among
experimental group adolescent girls with dysmenorrhea before and after
acupressure
3. To compare the effectiveness of acupressure
on menstrual pain among adolescent girls with dysmenorrhea in both the groups
4. To find out the association between post
test scores of menstrual pain among experimental group and control group of
adolescent girls with dysmenorrhea with their selected demographic variables.
OPERATIONAL DEFINITION:
1. Acupressure:
|
Acupressure Points and Location |
|
|
1. Sanyinjiao point (San Yin Jiao (SP6) This is located on the inside of leg, just above ankle. To find this
point, (1) locate the highest peak of the ankle (2) four finger widths up
leg, apply deep pressure slightly behind the bone (tibia) 2. Grandfather Grandson ( SP4) This point is located in the upper arch of the foot, one thumb width
from the ball of the foot. Apply deep pressure slightly behind the bone. |
|
|
Technique / Procedure |
|
1.
The adolescent girls was made to lie down/ sit
comfortably |
|
2. The investigator
was given acupressure to the alternate legs at the Sanyinjiao
point (San Yin Jiao (SP6) and Grandfather Grandson (SP4)
acupoints. For each pressure cycle on each side SP6
and SP4 was pressed with a thumb for 6 seconds and released for 2
seconds without pressure. |
|
3. This was continued
for 5 minutes on each point on each leg, to bring the total duration of 20
minutes |
|
4. Treatment duration
20 minutes (10 minutes in each leg) once in day for 6 days. (3 days before menstruation and 3 days after menstruation) |
RESEARCH
HYPOTHESIS:
H1: There will be a significant reduction in
menstrual pain among control than experimental group of adolescent girls with
dysmenorrhea before and after acupressure.
H2: There will be a significant effectiveness of
acupressure on menstrual pain among adolescent girls with dysmenorrhea.
H3: There will be a significant association
between post test scores of menstrual pain among experimental group and control
group of adolescent girls with dysmenorrhea with their selected demographic
variables.
METHODOLOGY:
Quantitative research design – True Experimental
design – pre and post test with control group design. The study was conducted
with permission of Head Master from SDA School, Erode. The sample consisted of
30 adolescent girls with
dysmenorrhea who
fulfil the inclusion criteria were chosen for the study by using simple random
sampling technique. The tools used to collect the data were demographic
variables and Visual analogue pain scale. The experimental group received acupressure once in a
day for 6 days. Both the groups’ data were collected after 4th day
of menstruation. Descriptive and inferential statistical methods were used to
analyse the data.
RESULTS AND DISCUSSIONS:
The study findings showed that majority of the sample
(87% and 73%) were in the age group of 13 years, 80 and 67% were educated, 87
and 73% were age at menarche 12 years, 80% and 83% of them had 7 days menstrual
flow, 86% and 73% of them had 21 – 24 days menstrual cycle ad family history of
dysmenorrhea.
1.
Level of menstrual pain among control group
adolescent girls with dysmenorrhea before and after acupressure reveals that, in control group
during pre test majority (80%) of them were severe pain and 20% of them were
moderate pain whereas in post test 70% of the had severe pain and 30% of them
had moderate pain.
2. Level of
menstrual pain among experimental group adolescent girls with dysmenorrhea
before and after acupressure reveals that, in experimental group
during pre test majority (87%) of them were severe pain and 13% of them were
moderate pain whereas in post test 93% of the had mild pain and 7% of them had
moderate pain.
3. Level of menstrual pain among control and experimental group
adolescent girls with dysmenorrhea after acupressure reveals that, in control group
during post test majority (70%) of them were severe pain and 30% of them were
moderate pain whereas in experimental group most (93%) of the had mild pain and
7% of them had moderate pain.
Compare the
effectiveness of acupressure on menstrual pain among adolescent girls with
dysmenorrhea in both the groups reveals that,
|
Adolescent girls with dysmenorrhea |
Before Intervention |
||
|
Mean |
SD |
Mean % |
|
|
Control group |
7.32 |
1.23 |
73 |
|
Experimental group |
7.52 |
1.26 |
75 |
|
Adolescent girls with dysmenorrhea |
After Intervention |
Paired ‘t’ test P < 0.05 |
||
|
Mean |
SD |
Mean % |
||
|
Control group |
6.83 |
1.18 |
68 |
4.26 |
|
Experimental group |
3.13 |
0.83 |
30 |
18.47 |
The paired ‘t’
test value was 4. 26 in control group whereas in experimental group 18.47 which
was statistically highly significant at p< 0.05 level. Avinash
Kaur Rana (2014)
recommended that there was significant difference in the mean pain score of
Numerical Pain Rating Scale before intervention, immediately after, at 1 hour,
at 2 hour and at 3 hour was 6.05, 4.05, 3.35, 2.68 and 2.24 respectively. Mean
score of Modified Menstrual Distress Questionnaire was 24.65 before applying
acupressure and after it was reduced to 9.98. The repeated measure ANOVA was
applied in subsequent observations determined statistically significant
reduction in the severity of dysmenorrhea (p< 0.001). So, acupressure is an
effective way in reducing dysmenorrhea.
There is no
statistical significant association was found in post test scores of level of
menstrual pain among adolescent girls with dysmenorrheal in control group and
experimental group with demographic variables such as age, education, age at
menarche, Duration of menstrual flow, days of menstrual cycle and family history of dysmenorrheal at P<0.05
level of significance.
CONCLUSION:
The present study assessed the effectiveness of
acupressure on menstrual pain among adolescent girls with dysmenorrheal. The
study findings revealed that acupressure was effective in reducing
dysmenorrheal among adolescent girls. It is simple, effective and safe method.
This method practiced during menstrual period is more helpful for the
adolescent girls to enhance the menstrual pain and distress. The study suggests
that long term acupressure use will not cause any problems in the menstrual
complications.
REFERENCES:
1.
National Family Health Survey, Report of the Working
Group on adolescents for the Tenth Five Year Plan, GOI, Planning Commission,
June 2001.
2.
Dutta. D.C Textbook of Gynecology.
6 Ed Calcutta: New Central Book Agency; 2004.p.565
3. Arminder Singh et. al. Prevalance severity of dysmenorrheal: A problem related to
menstruation. Indian Journal of Physiological Pharmacology, 2008: 52 [4];
389-97
4. French L.
Dysmenorrhea, American Family Physician, 2005; 71[2]: 285- 91
5. Gurates. B. Severity of
pain and management in primary dysmenorrhea, Achieves Gynecological Obstetrics,
2009:14 [2]; 421-25.
6. Wang. M.C. et.al.
Effects of circular acupressure on menstrual symptoms for women with primary
dysmenorrhea: Journal of alternative and complementary medicine, 2009; 15 [3]:
p.242-53.
7. Banikarim. C, Chacke. M.R, Kelder S.H.
Prevalence and impact of dysmenorrhea on Hispanic female adolescents. Arch
Pediatric Adolescents. 2000 Dec; 154 [12]:1226-29.
8. Agarwal AK, A study of
dysmenorrhea during menstruation in adolescent girls. Indian Journal of Community
Medicine 2010; 35:159-64
9. Jun EM, Chang S,
Kang DH, Kim S. Effects of acupressure on dysmenorrhea and skin temperature
changes in college students: a non-randomized controlled trial. International Journal
for Nursing Students. 2007 Aug; 44 [6]:
973-81
10.
Esha Sharma, Avinash Kaur
Rana, Amarjit Singh, An
interventional study to assess the effectiveness of acupressure at SP6 point on
dysmenorrhea among B. Sc Nursing Students, Nursing and Midwifery Research.
Received on 11.09.2015 Modified on 28.09.2015
Accepted on 12.10.2015 © A&V Publications all right reserved
Int. J. Adv. Nur. Management 4(1): Jan. - Mar. 2016; Page 1-5
DOI: 10.5958/2454-2652.2016.00001.9